• About
    • Our Attorneys
    • Verdicts and Settlements
    • Community
      • Sponsorship Request
      • Partnerships
      • Project Backpack
    • Testimonials
    • Scholarships
      • Cancer Scholarship
    • Careers
    • Our Core Values
  • Practice Areas
    • Car Accident
    • Truck Accident
    • Motorcycle Accident
    • Product Liability
    • Mesothelioma
    • Workers Compensation
    • Dog Bite
    • Slip and Fall
    • Wrongful Death
    • Maritime Injury
    • Pedestrian Accident
    • Dangerous Drugs
    • Defective Devices
    • Mass Torts
    • Premises Liability
    • View All Practice Areas
  • Areas we Serve
    • Lafayette
    • Alexandria
    • New Iberia
    • Marksville
    • New Orleans
    • Monroe
    • Arnaudville
    • Baton Rouge
    • Breaux Bridge
    • Broussard
    • Cankton
    • Carencro
    • Cecilia
    • Duson
    • Cade Coteau
    • Grand Coteau
    • Lake Charles
    • Opelousas
    • View All Areas We Serve
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • FAQs
    • Videos
    • For Referring Attorneys
  • Hurricanes
  • Contact Us
Available 24/7 • 365 Days (337) 777-7777 Hablamos Español
(337) 777-7777 Hablamos Español
No Win - No Fee AVAILABLE 24/7

Can You Negotiate a Car Accident Settlement?

Put 350 Years of Experience in Your Corner GET A FREE CASE EVALUATION
Louisiana Proud
Attorney David Laborde | Attorney Digger Earles
  1. Home
  2. FAQs
  3. Can You Negotiate a Car Accident Settlement?
On This Page
  1. Understanding the Value of Your Claim
  2. How Can You Prepare to Negotiate with an Insurance Adjuster?
  3. Maximizing Your Car’s Value in a Settlement
  4. Our Lafayette Car Accident Lawyers Are Ready to Handle Any Insurance Company
  5. Tips for Negotiating a Stronger Auto Accident Settlement
  6. Start Your Journey Toward Justice With Laborde Earles
Contact Us Today

Get The Help
You Need

I NEED HELP NOW

Your personal injury lawyer can help you calculate your recoverable damages, which may include:

  • Medical Bills
  • Income Loss
  • Property Damage
  • Pain & Suffering
  • Emotional Distress
  • Lasting Disfigurement
Can You Negotiate a Car Accident Settlement?

Can you negotiate a car accident settlement? Yes, but it’s often not straightforward. Insurance companies push for quick, low offers that may not cover your full losses. Taking time to evaluate any offer is key to protecting your interests.

A Lafayette car accident lawyer can help when an insurance company’s offer falls short. Without legal support, insurers may try to take advantage of your situation. Having an attorney ensures your claim is taken seriously.

Negotiating a settlement involves addressing medical bills, property damage, and lost income. These details can strengthen your case, and working with someone knowledgeable lets you focus on recovery while they handle the process.

Understanding the Value of Your Claim

A Lafayette personal injury lawyer can assist in determining the full value of your claim after an accident. This involves carefully evaluating damages such as:

  • Medical expenses: Costs for treatment, medications, and follow-up care.
  • Lost wages: Income missed due to injuries preventing you from working.
  • Long-term disabilities: Ongoing physical or mental impairments.
  • Pain and suffering: Emotional and physical challenges caused by the accident.
  • Property damage: Repair or replacement costs for your vehicle or other belongings.

Proper documentation of these damages is critical to building a strong claim. Without detailed records, insurance companies may undervalue your case, leaving you with less than you’re entitled to.

Responding to lowball auto insurance settlement offers can be challenging. With thorough evidence and legal support, you can stand firm against unfair tactics and pursue a fair outcome.

CTA CTA

Laborde Earles injury was great for me they took care of me very fast and professional. If for any reason I need legal help they will be who I use.

Client
Call Us Today We Are Here For You
(337) 777-7777

How Can You Prepare to Negotiate with an Insurance Adjuster?

Negotiating with an insurance adjuster starts with understanding that their goal is to minimize payouts. It’s common for them to respond to your demand letter with a low counteroffer. To prepare, consider requesting 20%–25% more than your car’s estimated value to allow room for negotiation.

Before entering discussions, have both a target settlement amount and a minimum figure in mind. These predetermined numbers keep your negotiations focused and help you avoid settling for less than your claim is worth. If the initial offer is too low, decline and ask the adjuster to explain their reasoning before presenting a counteroffer.

Most claims are resolved through negotiation without needing to file a lawsuit. However, if the final offer remains unsatisfactory, legal action is an option worth considering.

CTA CTA

I thank God for Digger & David. I don’t know what we would have done if it hadn’t have been for them.

Rick Smith | Client
Contact Us Today We want to be there for you

Maximizing Your Car’s Value in a Settlement

When negotiating your car accident settlement, it’s important to recognize the strategies insurance companies use to justify lower repair costs. They often claim that certain replacements improve your vehicle rather than simply restoring it to its pre-accident condition.

You can counter these arguments by taking proactive steps. Ask your mechanic for a statement confirming that repairs are necessary and do not enhance the car’s value beyond its original state. Additionally, emphasize that the crash has diminished your car’s market value, even if some repairs could be considered improvements.

For non-repair-related damages, sharing how the accident has disrupted your life can help. Explaining its effects on your daily routine or well-being may lead to a more reasonable outcome.

CTA CTA

The reassurance from Digger and his staff gave me that renewed hope that it’s going to be okay down the road.

Client
Call Us - (337) 777-7777 We are here when you need us the most

Our Lafayette Car Accident Lawyers Are Ready to Handle Any Insurance Company

As a Lafayette car accident attorney, we are well-equipped to take on negotiations with any insurance provider. Whether you’re dealing with a large national company or a smaller insurer, our team knows how to stand up for your rights. We regularly negotiate settlements with insurance companies such as:

  • Allstate
  • Geico
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Progressive
  • State Farm
  • USAA

Our experience with these companies means we understand their tactics and know how to pursue a fair resolution for your claim. Let us handle the negotiations so you can focus on moving forward.

CTA CTA

They treated us like no other people would. Whenever we needed something they were there for us. I put my trust in them and I don’t regret it.

Client
Contact Us Today We will work to get you the best outcome for your case

Tips for Negotiating a Stronger Auto Accident Settlement

After handling thousands of negotiations, we’ve learned strategies that can help maximize your settlement. Here are some key points to keep in mind:

  • Don’t rush to settle: Insurance adjusters may push for a quick resolution, but it’s often too early to understand the full extent of your injuries and losses. Waiting until you have a clearer picture of your recovery can lead to a more accurate settlement.
  • Decline low initial offers: Many insurance companies start with offers that don’t reflect the true value of your claim. These lowball figures often rely on claimants’ lack of information or urgent need for funds. Patience and persistence usually lead to better results.
  • Document everything: Accurate records of your medical expenses, lost income, and the emotional toll of the accident are essential. Proof of these losses strengthens your claim and prevents the insurer from undervaluing your damages.
  • Follow medical advice: Adhering to prescribed treatments shows that you are taking your recovery seriously. Failing to follow through could give the insurance company a reason to argue that your injuries aren’t as severe as claimed.
  • Understand your policy: If dealing with your own insurance company, reviewing your policy can clarify what is covered and help you stay focused on realistic expectations during negotiations.
  • Hire an attorney early: Having a Lafayette car accident attorney by your side from the start can provide the guidance and advocacy needed to handle the negotiation process with confidence.

By following these tips, you can be better prepared to negotiate a fair settlement for your car accident claim. If you’re unsure about any aspect of the process, reaching out to a Lafayette car accident attorney can help you make informed decisions and advocate for your best interests.

Start Your Journey Toward Justice With Laborde Earles

Can you negotiate a car accident settlement? Yes, and with the right support, you can pursue a fair outcome. At Laborde Earles, we’ve helped thousands of clients negotiate with insurance companies to recover what they need to move forward.

With over $1 billion won for our clients and more than 350 years of combined experience, our team knows how to handle even the toughest negotiations. We understand the tactics insurers use and are prepared to fight for what matters most to you.

If you’re dealing with an insurance settlement, having the right support can make all the difference. Laborde Earles is here to guide you through the process and pursue a resolution that addresses the full extent of your damages. Contact us today to get started.

 

Car Accident Blog Posts:
I-10 Basin Bridge Speed Limit Change Addresses Safety Issues

I-10 Basin Bridge Speed Limit Change Addresses Safety Issues

The Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development (DOTD) changed the I-10 Basin Bridge speed limit to 60 miles per hour for all motorists. They also implemented "your speed" feedback signs to...

Laborde Earles to Represent the Hall Family’s Fatal Crash Lawsuit Against Kyren Lacy

Following a tragic collision in December on LA 20, attorney Digger Earles of Laborde Earles will represent the Hall family as they pursue compensation for the wrongful death of Herman Hall, 78. The...

Why We Are

The Best Choice For You

Over 1,000+ 5-Star Google Reviews Across Our Locations
Over $1 Billion Recovered For Our Clients
An Award-Winning Team in Your Corner
You Get the Full Team on Your Case, Including David & Digger
Communication with You is a Top Priority
We Give Back to Our Communities

No Fee Unless We Win Your Case

Available 24 hours a day • 7 days a week
GET YOUR FREE CASE EVALUATION
Car Accidents FAQ:
What if My Car Accident Claim Was Denied by State Farm? What if My Car Accident Claim Was Denied by State Farm?

If State Farm denies your car accident claim, you may still be able to secure compensation, and a Lafayette car accident lawyer can help. An experienced attorney can assess your unique situation and

Average Lyft Accident Settlement Amount Average Lyft Accident Settlement Amount

  There is no average Lyft accident settlement amount as each case varies. Many cases are settled privately, too, making it difficult to determine the average settlement amount. There are

Do You Know the Single Most Important Step to Take Following a Collision? Do You Know the Single Most Important Step to Take Following a Collision?

Motor vehicle collisions can be traumatizing, especially if serious injuries or substantial property damage occurs. In fact, according to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, researchers estimate

Contact Us Form
CONTACT US TODAY NO WIN, NO FEE GUARANTEE
Name(Required)
Name(Required)
Untitled
Untitled

FAQ Categories
  • Accidents in Intersection
  • Bicycle Accident
  • Car Accidents
  • Defective Product
  • Dog Bite
  • Head Injury
  • Hurricane Damage
  • Jones Act
  • Knee Injury
  • Maritime Injury
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Mesothelioma
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Neck Injury
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Rear End Collisions
  • Rideshare Accidents
  • Robocalling
  • Sexual Abuse
  • Slip and Fall Injury
  • Spinal Cord Injury
  • Traumatic Brain Injury
  • Truck Accidents
  • Whiplash Injury
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Wrongful Death
  • Zantac

 

Frequently Asked Questions
What If My Bicycle Accident Claim Was Denied By USAA? What If My Bicycle Accident Claim Was Denied By USAA?
What Should I Do in the Days Following a Truck Accident? What Should I Do in the Days Following a Truck Accident?
How Will My Lawyer Calculate My Workers’ Compensation? How Will My Lawyer Calculate My Workers’ Compensation?
Find Yourself a Passionate Lawyer Now!
  • Erath Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Orange Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Shreveport Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Sherburne Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Harvey Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Freeport Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Egan Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Monroe Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Coteau Holmes Personal Injury Lawyer
  • Chataignier Personal Injury Lawyer
How can we help you

How We Can Help You

Let our injury attorneys help you maximize the compensation you deserve to turn your life back around.


Contact us today if you want to tell us about your accident. We have someone available to discuss your situation at all times of the day.

Contact Us

(337) 777-7777

FREE Case Evaluation

No Win - No Fee
Name(Required)
Name(Required)
Email Opt In
SMS Opt in

Contact Us

(337) 777-7777

OFFICE LOCATIONS

Lafayette
1901 Kaliste Saloom Rd,
Lafayette, LA 70508

Phone : (337) 777-7777

Alexandria
100 Versailles Blvd, Suite A,
Alexandria, LA 71303

Phone : (318) 777-7777

Marksville
306 North Washington Street, Suite A,
Marksville, LA 71351

Phone : (318) 310-8922

New Iberia
230 W. Main Street,
New Iberia, LA 70560

Phone : (337)-547-2777

Lake Charles
530 E College St,
Lake Charles, LA 70605

Phone : (337) 612-6909

New Orleans
821 Baronne St, Suite D,
New Orleans, LA 70113

Phone : (504) 777-7777

Baton Rouge
660 St Ferdinand St,
Baton Rouge, LA 70802

Phone : (225) 777-7777

Practice Areas

  • Bicycle Accident
  • Car Accident
  • Dangerous Drugs
  • Dog Bite
  • Maritime Injury
  • Mass Torts
  • Motorcycle Accident
  • Pedestrian Accident
  • Premises Liability
  • Product Liability
  • Toxic Torts
  • Truck Accident
  • Slip and Fall
  • Wrongful Death

About Links

  • Our Attorneys
  • Verdicts and Settlements
  • Community
  • Testimonials
  • Scholarships

Leave a Review

  • LAFAYETTE
  • ALEXANDRIA
  • MARKSVILLE
  • NEW ORLEANS
  • NEW IBERIA
  • LAKE CHARLES
  • BATON ROUGE

Copyright © Laborde Earles Injury Lawyers 2025.
All Rights Reserved.

Disclaimer / Privacy Policy / Sitemap

Hennessey-Digital-Badge